In our house, we eat butter.
Lots of butter.
We also use coconut oil and olive oil, but definitely butter. I began buying Kerrygold butter at our local Kroger a few months ago, and while it is more spendy than the store brand butter, it is visibly different in color and texture, and is from the cream of grass-fed cows. I like that. The flavor is fantastic as well!
I have wanted to make butter since we started participating in a herd share program for raw milk 6 years ago, but was very spotty in actually doing it. It takes time and some bit of practice and patience to get it done, in my experience.
A couple months ago, I became resolved to make butter consistently from our milk, and it’s really coming along! I know that there are many tutorials out there for making butter, but I got into a FB conversation with another butter lover and decided I would share my way here. Maybe you do it, too and have some tips for me – or maybe I do something that can help you! The pictures aren’t the best and I took more in better light during another session, but they are still on my phone

I also have a couple little videos for you to see what it looks like. Are you visual like me? I’ll get those up soon and update you folks on that.
We get 3 gallons a week from our herd share at
Sweet Land Farm in the Floyd area. From these 3 gallons, I pull about 4 cups/1 quart of cream. I am not usually doing it all at one time, or as soon as we get home. Usually I am doing a rush job before someone starts pouring themselves a glass of milk! We use this butter in cooking and for spreading on bread. My brother-in-law and his wife got us a butter bell a while back, and that keeps the butter soft for spreading. mmmmm….
So here is the {with eager hands } way to make butter :
1.Let the milk jugs sit still for a good while in the fridge, to make sure the milk and cream separate. Even a few hours after you put them in the fridge is ok. You can see the separation. The creamy top is the cream, and the milk is almost blue-tinted. It’s super faint, but it’s not as starch white as commercial milk.

2. Gather your tools for getting your cream: Batter Bowl (or other bowl with a lid, and a baster
3. Catch your cream, then put your cream in the fridge until you have time to make butter.
HOW TO CATCH YOUR CREAMI started getting the cream out with a small ladle, but have found this baster to be so much faster. That being said, it’s a cheap Vile-Mart baster, and now that I am dedicated to doing this weekly, I want to get a higher-quality (read: not plastic) tool. This is STRICTLY for the cream-catching and washed IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING the catching. Otherwise, the process is a pain in my elbow, ya’ll.
I get my bowl right up against my milk jug and a clean surface to lay the baster while I switch from one jug to the next. Then, basically, I slowly suck the cream out of the jug. Below is sort of how I do it, because you have to be careful not to suck the milk out with it.
I squish the basting bubble at the top (what is that called, anyway?) BEFORE putting it in the milk. Very important, folks. I put the tip of baster in the milk, only a smidgen! I then slowly let it open up in my hand, while moving my hand to guide it around the edge of the jug.

In the beginning it’s not a big deal if you just stick the end in the middle and suck, but you’re likely to get the milk, so I just always run it around the edge. This way, you can see the tip of the baster and also see if you are messing up the cream-milk line. If you see that line skew, you know you’ve hit the milk. I take my time here, letting my OCD fly. I try to suck as much cream out as possible (more butter!!) and not any milk.
As you can see below, I left a bit. Since this picture, I have done several more batches and can a bit more out. But, still, that’s a lot, considering it went to the very top.

In the picture below, the left milk jug has been creamed and shaken – just because I like to – and the right jug is one not yet creamed.

4. When you are ready to make butter (or some time in the next few hours) get it out and give it some time on the counter (covered so nothing falls or flies in there) to warm up a bit. If it’s fridge-cold, then you have to run the machine longer to make it separate. Gather the rest of your tools during this time: food processor, a couple quart Mason jars and lids, fine mesh sieve, canning funnel, small bowl, Pampered Chef Small Mix ‘N Scraper (it needs to be this one. It is awesome.)
5. Pour it into the food processor bowl (unless that’s where you put the cream to begin with) and let ‘er rip! I do it on “1”.

In the above picture, I haven’t gotten started, and it just looks like cream. When I ramp it up, it will ride up the sides….like cream would do, lol! You have to let it run for a few minutes, but exactly how long depends on the temperature of your cream, the machine and the way you hold your head (just joking about that last one.)
After a while, you will see the contents beginning to behave differently in there whilst spinning. It begins to clump a little and slide down the sides, like this:

And when you open up to see if you have butter, you might see this:

It’s not butter yet, but you can see that it is beginning to come! Church, butter churn! Close it up, turn ‘er back on, and let it go some more! At some point, maybe 2 more minutes (give or take), will change more…..

Do you see the separation? The butter is in the back, clumped up, and there is white milk at the bottom.
BUTTER!

6. After you see the butter, stop the machine and pour the “buttered milk” (as I say) into one of the mason jars outfitted with the blue canning funnel with a fine mesh sieve on top.

That sieve catches any clumps of butter that might fall out.

Label this and fridge it up. You can use this instead of regular milk in any recipe you have – or even drink it!

It is a little sweet and has a buttery taste. Laura Ingalls liked it!
7. We don’t have an ice maker, so I just pour cold water (I have started pouring a good 1/2 cup or more in there) into the bowl and then run the machine for a minute or 3. (Can you see the water at the top, all cloudy, and the butter on the bottom, slammed against the side of the bowl?)


This cold water and the agitation will draw more of the milk from the butter. I then move the funnel and and sieve to the second mason jar and save this watery-buttered milk and the next round and label it so. Again, you can use it in place of regular milk. I was dumping this all, and just felt so bad about that – there is STILL milk in there, you know!
8. I will drain the butter of the water-with-less-and-less-milk, refill with more clean cold water and run the processor until the water is clear. I do this routine several times. It won’t be perfectly clear, veeeeery nearly so. At that point, I take my butter out of the food processor bowl and put it in a small bowl. I squoosh the butter with the back of the scraper and it makes more water come out.



Pretty soon after starting, I will add about 1 teaspoon salt (we use RealSalt brand) for flavor and a smidge of preservation. Then I squoosh more, pouring out the water now and again. This is where my patience is tried, to be honest. It’s not hard, but it’s teaching me to slow down……much like kneading bread.
9. After I squoosh until I am not seeing water come out, or only a drop or so, I will put it in a small bowl, like one of those Pampered Chef Prep Bowls that hold 1 cup of something up to the top (and it has a lid, yaya!) I have found that squooshing in the bowl brings more water out.

We go through the butter in a week’s time, but in the past, I wasn’t getting al the milk out and it was souring a bit. From raw milk, cultured butter is very healthy, but none of us like it here, so I like to keep it sweet cream

Baby steps, right? I am getting better and as I find myself being consistent in this, I hope to use the spring butter and early fall butter to save for the winter months. Did you know that the grass grown in those times is even better than the rest of the growing season? The milk, then, has even higher vitamin counts! Next year, then!
I’d love to hear your tips for making butter!
Linking up: